{ "head": "3c207fcac42b45702ac3141214f7ce29bd073fcc", "behavior_probes": [ { "case": "valid canonical owned mapping retains rule", "errors": 0, "messages": [], "population": [ { "section_id": "independent-contract", "row_number": "1", "rule": "The independent example must be retained.", "source": "AGENTS.md", "scorecard_classification": "Judgment", "classification": "Mechanical", "authority": "corpus", "entry_id": "independent-entry" } ] }, { "case": "owned Mechanical overrides Judgment", "errors": 1, "messages": [ "Bullet-retention violation: invariant-tier 'Mechanical' bullet not found verbatim in per-turn surface.\n Bullet: 'The independent example must be retained.'\n Classification source: corpus entry 'independent-entry' (section 'owned' of AGENTS.md is corpus-owned; ADR-0.35.0 \u00a7 Decision item 9).\n Why: ADR-0.0.33 Invariant 1 requires invariant-tier content to render verbatim at every setpoint (tier-scoped amendment 2026-06-03).\n Fix: restore the bullet text verbatim to AGENTS.md/CLAUDE.md/.claude/rules, or re-classify it compressible in the corpus and record an advisor-QC verdict.\n Source: docs/governance/advisory-rules-audit.md" ], "population": [ { "section_id": "independent-contract", "row_number": "1", "rule": "The independent example must be retained.", "source": "AGENTS.md", "scorecard_classification": "Judgment", "classification": "Mechanical", "authority": "corpus", "entry_id": "independent-entry" } ] }, { "case": "canonical owned source missing entry", "errors": 1, "messages": [ "Bullet-retention mapping violation: scorecard row independent-contract #1 sits in corpus-owned section 'owned' but cites no entry id.\n Bullet: 'The independent example must be retained.'\n Why: ADR-0.35.0 \u00a7 Decision item 9 \u2014 every row names the one surface that classifies it, and a row whose mapping is broken is never answered by the scorecard instead.\n Fix: record `source=# entry=` in the row's Notes column (live entry ids are in .gzkit/corpus/.jsonl), then re-run `uv run gz validate --bullet-retention`.\n Source: docs/governance/advisory-rules-audit.md" ], "population": [] }, { "case": "same owned source with dot slash missing entry", "errors": 0, "messages": [], "population": [ { "section_id": "independent-contract", "row_number": "1", "rule": "The independent example must be retained.", "source": "./AGENTS.md", "scorecard_classification": "Judgment", "classification": "Judgment", "authority": "scorecard", "entry_id": null } ] }, { "case": "canonical skill source lacks rule", "errors": 1, "messages": [ "Bullet-retention violation: 'Mechanical' scorecard row independent-contract #1 is not found verbatim in its attributed source '.gzkit/skills/example/SKILL.md'.\n Bullet: 'The independent example must be retained.'\n Why: ADR-0.0.33 Invariant 1, source-aware per OBPI-0.35.0-10 (GHI #939) \u2014 a skill- or ADR-sourced discipline is retained against that source's own text and is never exempt.\n Fix: restore the bullet text verbatim to .gzkit/skills/example/SKILL.md, or correct the row's `source=` attribution, then re-run `uv run gz validate --bullet-retention`.\n Source: docs/governance/advisory-rules-audit.md" ], "population": [ { "section_id": "independent-contract", "row_number": "1", "rule": "The independent example must be retained.", "source": ".gzkit/skills/example/SKILL.md", "scorecard_classification": "Mechanical", "classification": "Mechanical", "authority": "scorecard", "entry_id": null } ] }, { "case": "same skill source with dot slash lacks rule", "errors": 0, "messages": [], "population": [ { "section_id": "independent-contract", "row_number": "1", "rule": "The independent example must be retained.", "source": "./.gzkit/skills/example/SKILL.md", "scorecard_classification": "Mechanical", "classification": "Mechanical", "authority": "scorecard", "entry_id": null } ] }, { "case": "unmapped Ambiguous entry with ownership", "errors": 1, "messages": [ "Bullet-retention classification violation: corpus-owned section 'owned' of 'AGENTS.md' carries the capture default 'Ambiguous' on: independent-entry.\n Why: ADR-0.35.0 \u00a7 Decision item 9 \u2014 owning a section makes its entries' classification binding, so an unreviewed capture default may not author a gate verdict.\n Fix: for each entry run `uv run gz content retire AGENTS.md --entry --reason \"\"`, capture the reviewed class with `uv run gz content remember AGENTS.md --section owned --text \"\" --classification `, publish with `uv run gz content land AGENTS.md`, then re-run `uv run gz validate --bullet-retention`.\n Source: docs/governance/advisory-rules-audit.md" ], "population": [ { "section_id": "independent-contract", "row_number": "1", "rule": "The independent example must be retained.", "source": "AGENTS.md", "scorecard_classification": "Judgment", "classification": "Judgment", "authority": "scorecard", "entry_id": null } ] }, { "case": "ownership declaration deleted genesis remains", "errors": 0, "messages": [], "population": [ { "section_id": "independent-contract", "row_number": "1", "rule": "The independent example must be retained.", "source": "AGENTS.md", "scorecard_classification": "Judgment", "classification": "Judgment", "authority": "scorecard", "entry_id": null } ] }, { "case": "no parsed rows despite owned Ambiguous entry", "errors": 0, "messages": [], "population": [] }, { "case": "ownership JSON is a list", "exception": "AttributeError", "message": "'list' object has no attribute 'get'" }, { "case": "ownership floor is null", "exception": "TypeError", "message": "'>' not supported between instances of 'int' and 'NoneType'" } ], "population": { "actual_before": 178, "actual_after": 178, "removed": [], "added": [], "audited_count": 173, "omitted": [ { "identity": [ "changelog-release-notes-gzkit-rules-changelog-release-notes-md", "65" ], "score": "**Mechanical** (changelog structure) / **Judgment** (release-notes curation)", "attributed": false }, { "identity": [ "data-models-gzkit-rules-models-md", "27" ], "score": "**Mechanical**", "attributed": false }, { "identity": [ "map-not-encyclopedia-doctrine-gzkit-rules-agents-md-map-doctrine-md", "58" ], "score": "**Mechanical** (shape invariant); per-section size targets remain **Judgment**", "attributed": false }, { "identity": [ "model-selection-gzkit-rules-model-selection-md", "52" ], "score": "**Mechanical**", "attributed": false }, { "identity": [ "pythonic-standards-gzkit-rules-pythonic-md", "22" ], "score": "**Mechanical**", "attributed": false } ] }, "freshness": { "files_changed": [ "docs/governance/advisory-rules-audit.md", "docs/user/manpages/validate.md", ".gzkit/corpus/AGENTS.md.jsonl", ".gzkit/ownership/AGENTS.md.json", "AGENTS.md" ], "roster_unchanged": true, "included": { "docs/governance/advisory-rules-audit.md": false, "docs/user/manpages/validate.md": false, ".gzkit/corpus/AGENTS.md.jsonl": false, ".gzkit/ownership/AGENTS.md.json": false, "AGENTS.md": false } } }