{
  "schema_version": 1,
  "persona": "quality-reviewer",
  "independent": true,
  "source_protocol": "docs/evals/three-pillars-current-2026-09-19/protocol.md",
  "source_oracle": "docs/evals/three-pillars-current-2026-09-19/cases.json",
  "snapshot": "/tmp/gzkit-current-snapshot",
  "scoring_notes": [
    "D=specific discovery; R=causal relationship; A=consistent proposed application; complete requires all three.",
    "Exact short quotes are raw-answer excerpts; notes identify missing evidence and semantic-equivalence decisions.",
    "Optional unchanged regressions are not required. Preservation of existing contracts can establish application without a prescribed test inventory.",
    "S3 credits explicit exit/quality propagation as semantic evidence; child returncode retention is implicit across smoke responses, retained as ambiguity for primary adjudication.",
    "C04 S6 credits an end-after-execution timer plus subsequent gate comparison as semantic post-run enforcement; explicit timeout wording is absent.",
    "No other evaluations, working-tree repair, or current code outside the snapshot were inspected. Snapshot was used only for smoke consumer/prose witness clarification."
  ],
  "runs": [
    {
      "id": "C01",
      "task": "current_flag_mention_boundary",
      "criteria": [
        {
          "id": "F1",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 1,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "checks `if flag in content`. Thus a manpage containing only `--output-format` satisfies `--output`",
          "note": "Distinguishes truth matching; proposes exact mention and delimiter positive tests.",
          "complete": true
        },
        {
          "id": "F2",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 1,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "A newly detected presence gap therefore affects the command and quality outcome, even though the command-level cross-coverage report can remain green.",
          "note": "Canonical paths, JSON failure, issue and CLI nonzero test covered.",
          "complete": true
        },
        {
          "id": "F3",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 0,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "No parser-discovery or manifest-schema change is needed for the stated example.",
          "note": "Discovers existing stream and preserves exact waivers; does not demonstrate that manifest governs command obligations rather than serving as a flag filter. No active authority violation.",
          "complete": false
        },
        {
          "id": "F4",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 1,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "It checks requiredness and value-taking only in fenced Usage/Synopsis blocks. Presence and truth deliberately answer different questions.",
          "note": "Preserves whole-document presence, usage-only truth, and missing-page delegation.",
          "complete": true
        },
        {
          "id": "F5",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 1,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "Update the coverage docstring’s explicit substring promise and clarify the presence assertion",
          "note": "Uses one spec scan and proposes real-manpage audit without claiming census results.",
          "complete": true
        }
      ],
      "flags": {
        "unsupported_scope": [],
        "unsafe_policy_changes": [],
        "false_execution_claims": []
      },
      "total": {
        "D": 5,
        "R": 4,
        "A": 5,
        "complete": 4,
        "criteria": 5
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C02",
      "task": "current_smoke_elapsed_scope",
      "criteria": [
        {
          "id": "S1",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 1,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "phase-driven advancement must distinguish that mutation.",
          "note": "Timer before collect; fake clock advanced independently in collection/selection and execution.",
          "complete": true
        },
        {
          "id": "S2",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 1,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "A test failure takes precedence (1); successful runs exceeding the budget return 3; equality passes.",
          "note": "Same elapsed for print and comparison; code default/override retained. Does not explicitly discuss rounding; preservation of unchanged comparison supplies semantic consistency.",
          "complete": true
        },
        {
          "id": "S3",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 1,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "The wrapper raises `SystemExit` for nonzero results.",
          "note": "Also identifies subprocess full-check consumer, corrected verdict inheritance, and mocked subprocess propagation verification. QualityResult field spelling and retained code assertion are implicit; semantic credit with ambiguity.",
          "complete": true
        },
        {
          "id": "S4",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 0,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "With no marked files, it returns advisory success unless `smoke.required` is true, when it returns 3.",
          "note": "Identifies observed opt-in behavior and preserves it, but does not identify contradictory unconditional empty-tier prose. Other prose conflict (full-tier budget) does not establish this criterion.",
          "complete": false
        },
        {
          "id": "S5",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 1,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "Preserve ... live discovery and marker filtering",
          "note": "Preserves membership; proposes nested marked/unmarked verification. Optional unchanged decorator details not required.",
          "complete": true
        },
        {
          "id": "S6",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 1,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "This is post-run enforcement, not a timeout that interrupts discovery or execution.",
          "note": "Runner/help/manpage/rule timing wording and unchanged ceiling covered.",
          "complete": true
        }
      ],
      "flags": {
        "unsupported_scope": [
          {
            "quote": "reconcile this touched explanatory surface",
            "note": "Proposes reconciling full-unit larger-budget prose beyond pure timing scope. Coupled recovery guidance is plausibly justified; retain as scope ambiguity, not unsafe ceiling rewrite."
          }
        ],
        "unsafe_policy_changes": [],
        "false_execution_claims": [],
        "protocol_exposure": [
          {
            "quote": "broad chores search incidentally exposed proof/audit snippets, including pair-review material",
            "note": "Self-reported exposure, explicitly not used; independent score does not certify clean boundary."
          }
        ]
      },
      "total": {
        "D": 6,
        "R": 5,
        "A": 6,
        "complete": 5,
        "criteria": 6
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C03",
      "task": "current_flag_mention_boundary",
      "criteria": [
        {
          "id": "F1",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 1,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "checks `if flag in content`. Therefore a manpage containing only `--output-format` satisfies coverage for `--output`.",
          "note": "Distinguishes truth; tests exact positive and delimiters.",
          "complete": true
        },
        {
          "id": "F2",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 1,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "A flag finding can therefore coexist with passing command-level coverage without requiring a schema change.",
          "note": "Canonical issue path and CLI JSON/exit collision verification covered.",
          "complete": true
        },
        {
          "id": "F3",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 0,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "Preserve ... the shared AST discovery.",
          "note": "Discovers correct flag stream and protects waivers, but does not demonstrate manifest command-obligation authority versus per-flag discovery/filter distinction.",
          "complete": false
        },
        {
          "id": "F4",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 1,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "borrowing the truth check’s Usage-only scope would reject currently valid prose/example documentation.",
          "note": "Both scopes, historical prose truth regression, missing-page delegation preserved.",
          "complete": true
        },
        {
          "id": "F5",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 1,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "their identity/count needs a later census",
          "note": "Docstring/manpage update, single discovery, real census proposed without current gap claims.",
          "complete": true
        }
      ],
      "flags": {
        "unsupported_scope": [],
        "unsafe_policy_changes": [],
        "false_execution_claims": []
      },
      "total": {
        "D": 5,
        "R": 4,
        "A": 5,
        "complete": 4,
        "criteria": 5
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C04",
      "task": "current_smoke_elapsed_scope",
      "criteria": [
        {
          "id": "S1",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 1,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "fake monotonic clock advanced by discovery, selection, and execution",
          "note": "True measurement boundary and phase-sensitive test explicit.",
          "complete": true
        },
        {
          "id": "S2",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 1,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "Keep the CLI summary and enforcement bound to that same total, with rounding confined to display.",
          "note": "Default/override, strict comparison, failure precedence, boundary verification explicit.",
          "complete": true
        },
        {
          "id": "S3",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 1,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "They consume the same CLI exit rather than independently timing smoke",
          "note": "Full-check adapter identified; shell/quality-wrapper propagation proposed. SystemExit and QualityResult field spellings absent; semantic exit transport credit, with retained-child-code verification implicit and therefore ambiguous.",
          "complete": true
        },
        {
          "id": "S4",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 0,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "Empty static selection returns advisory success unless `SmokeConfig.required` is true",
          "note": "Observed opt-in behavior and preserving tests present; never identifies unconditional empty-tier prose conflict.",
          "complete": false
        },
        {
          "id": "S5",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 1,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "Unmarked tests are imported but not executed.",
          "note": "Preserves marker selection and verifies marked/unmarked nested cases.",
          "complete": true
        },
        {
          "id": "S6",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 1,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "Start the monotonic measurement before collection and end it after execution.",
          "note": "Docstring/manpage/help, unchanged ceiling and factual timing. Post-run nature follows proposed end-after-execution comparison; no explicit timeout distinction, semantic credit.",
          "complete": true
        }
      ],
      "flags": {
        "unsupported_scope": [
          {
            "quote": "correct that coupled operator guidance when editing it",
            "note": "Full-unit budget prose reconciliation proposed. Plausibly coupled recovery guidance, retain ambiguity separately."
          }
        ],
        "unsafe_policy_changes": [],
        "false_execution_claims": [],
        "protocol_exposure": [
          {
            "quote": "One broad design search inadvertently returned evaluation-scorecard snippets",
            "note": "Self-reported non-use; prevents clean exclusion-boundary certification."
          }
        ]
      },
      "total": {
        "D": 6,
        "R": 5,
        "A": 6,
        "complete": 5,
        "criteria": 6
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C05",
      "task": "current_flag_mention_boundary",
      "criteria": [
        {
          "id": "F1",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 1,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "uses `if flag in content`. Consequently, a document containing only `--output-format` satisfies `--output`.",
          "note": "Existing truth matcher distinguished, exact positive/delimiter verification explicit.",
          "complete": true
        },
        {
          "id": "F2",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 1,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "Command-level cross-coverage may still pass when flag coverage fails; its counters are not flag counters.",
          "note": "Canonical issue paths, combined JSON failure/CLI exit, otherwise-valid fixture explicit.",
          "complete": true
        },
        {
          "id": "F3",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 0,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "Preserve AST discovery, name/spec projections",
          "note": "Discovery and explicit waiver boundaries preserved. Does not demonstrate manifest's command-obligation authority versus flag discovery/per-flag filtering.",
          "complete": false
        },
        {
          "id": "F4",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 1,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "Neither check should acquire the other's scope.",
          "note": "Whole-page presence, fenced-usage truth, missing-page delegation explicit.",
          "complete": true
        },
        {
          "id": "F5",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 1,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "Audit newly exposed real-document gaps and repair genuine missing mentions rather than silently adding waivers.",
          "note": "Coupled docstring/manpage, existing population census test and discovery stream identified.",
          "complete": true
        }
      ],
      "flags": {
        "unsupported_scope": [],
        "unsafe_policy_changes": [],
        "false_execution_claims": []
      },
      "total": {
        "D": 5,
        "R": 4,
        "A": 5,
        "complete": 4,
        "criteria": 5
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "C06",
      "task": "current_smoke_elapsed_scope",
      "criteria": [
        {
          "id": "S1",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 1,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "A runner-only measurement must fail the assertion",
          "note": "Timer boundary, discovery/selection causal exclusion, phase-sensitive clock verification explicit.",
          "complete": true
        },
        {
          "id": "S2",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 1,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "compares that same unrounded value with the budget",
          "note": "Default/override and precise comparison/precedence supported by boundary tests.",
          "complete": true
        },
        {
          "id": "S3",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 1,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "`smoke_cmd` translates nonzero results into `SystemExit`; `cli.main` preserves those codes.",
          "note": "Quality adapter/full-check registry identified and quality-result propagation verified prospectively; exact child returncode assertion implicit, retain ambiguity.",
          "complete": true
        },
        {
          "id": "S4",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 0,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "An empty scan passes advisorially unless `smoke.required` is true",
          "note": "Observed opt-in and preservation identified, but contradictory unconditional empty-tier prose not named. Full-unit larger-budget conflict is a distinct finding.",
          "complete": false
        },
        {
          "id": "S5",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 1,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "Preserve discovery’s actual marked/unmarked selection semantics",
          "note": "Membership retained, expensive unmarked import effects explained. Unchanged metadata-only details optional.",
          "complete": true
        },
        {
          "id": "S6",
          "D": 1,
          "R": 1,
          "A": 1,
          "quote": "This remains post-run enforcement, not an interrupting timeout.",
          "note": "Coupled timing docs and fixed ceiling authority preserved.",
          "complete": true
        }
      ],
      "flags": {
        "unsupported_scope": [
          {
            "quote": "Reconcile touched explanations.",
            "note": "Full-unit larger-budget prose reconciliation proposed; plausibly coupled recovery guidance, retain scope ambiguity separately."
          }
        ],
        "unsafe_policy_changes": [],
        "false_execution_claims": [],
        "protocol_exposure": [
          {
            "quote": "Broad search accidentally returned an `EVALUATION_SCORECARD.md` match",
            "note": "Self-reported exclusion-boundary slip; non-use claimed, independently unverified."
          }
        ]
      },
      "total": {
        "D": 6,
        "R": 5,
        "A": 6,
        "complete": 5,
        "criteria": 6
      }
    }
  ]
}